How to reward yourself for habits

Habit science · 4 min read · Updated

To reward yourself for habits, reward a new habit right away, in a small way that doesn't undo it. An immediate, modest payoff, such as marking the day done or a moment of genuine satisfaction, teaches the habit faster than a big prize at the end of the month. Once the habit feels good on its own, rewards can fade.

Why timing matters more than size

Good habits tend to pay off late. A workout today improves your fitness in weeks. Saving today matters in years. The habit you're trying to replace usually pays off now. That's why rewards for new habits need to arrive within moments, not at the end of the month.

James Clear's fourth law in Atomic Habits is to make habits satisfying, for this reason. BJ Fogg goes further and argues that the feeling right after a behavior is what wires it in. His Tiny Habits method asks you to celebrate immediately, with a fist pump, a 'nice' or whatever produces a small feeling of success.

Rewards that work

The best rewards are immediate, small and consistent with the habit.

  • A small celebration: saying 'done' out loud, a fist pump, a smile. It sounds silly and takes one second.
  • Marking progress: filling in a day on a grid or calendar right after doing the habit.
  • Something you enjoy during the habit: a podcast on the walk, good music while cleaning.
  • A small treat that fits the goal: a good coffee after the morning run, a hot bath after a strength session.
  • Noticing the benefit: 30 seconds to register that the kitchen is clean or your head is clearer after meditating.
  • Transferring money: moving $5 to a savings pot for 'new running shoes' after each run.

Rewards that backfire

Some rewards work against the habit. A slice of cake after every workout cancels out much of what most people are training for. A shopping spree for a week of no-spend days defeats the point. Choose rewards that support the identity you're building.

Others are too big or too late. A holiday at the end of 90 days doesn't help on day 6. And unconditional rewards aren't rewards at all. If you get the treat whether or not you did the habit, it teaches nothing.

There's also a subtler risk with things you already enjoy. In a classic 1973 study by Mark Lepper, David Greene and Richard Nisbett, preschoolers who liked drawing and were promised a certificate for it later spent less of their free time drawing than children who weren't promised anything. An expected external reward can crowd out interest you already had.

When outside rewards help

For habits with little enjoyment at the start, external rewards can help get you going. In a 2009 study published in Econometrica, economists paid students to go to the gym regularly for a month. After the payments stopped, attendance stayed higher than before, mostly among people who hadn't been regular gym-goers.

The pattern across both studies suggests a rule of thumb. Use external rewards to start habits you don't yet enjoy. Avoid them for habits you already like doing.

Milestone rewards without the trap

Milestones are fine as long as they don't replace the daily payoff. Tie them to totals rather than unbroken streaks, so one miss doesn't wipe out the prize. 'New running shoes after 30 runs' survives a sick week. 'New shoes after 30 days in a row' doesn't.

Make the milestone reward support the habit where you can: a better yoga mat, a book you've wanted, a cooking class.

Phasing rewards out

After a couple of months, many habits start rewarding themselves. You feel better after a walk, the clean kitchen is pleasant, the book is good. At that point, extra rewards can drop away without the habit collapsing.

Test it by skipping the treat for a week. If the habit holds, you don't need it. If it wobbles, keep the reward a little longer or switch to a smaller one.

Keep the one-second celebration, though, or whatever version of it you use. It costs nothing, it never undermines the habit, and on the days the habit feels like a chore it is the one payoff you can always count on.

The record as a reward

For many people the simplest reward is seeing the day filled in. When you tell ChatGPT 'Done with my workout', the day's cell on the contribution grid fills with the habit's color, and over weeks the grid becomes something you don't want to leave blank. Asking 'What's my longest streak?' every so often gives you a number to beat.

Choose a color you like for each habit, from green, blue, purple, pink, red, orange, yellow or gray, and an emoji or icon. It's a small thing, but small immediate satisfactions are exactly what this page is about.

Track it

Questions

Is it bad to reward yourself with food?

Not always, but avoid food rewards that work against the habit's goal, such as dessert after a workout meant for weight loss. A favorite coffee or a meal you enjoy cooking can work if it fits your plan.

Should I reward myself every day?

In the early weeks, yes, in a small way. A one-second celebration or marking the day done is enough. Larger rewards are better kept for milestones.

What if no reward feels motivating?

The habit may be too big or too disconnected from something you care about. Shrink it, pair it with something you enjoy, or check whether a different habit would serve the same goal.

Sources

Read next

All guides

Turn it into a habit you can see

Free for up to 2 habits, every feature included. Log by chatting with ChatGPT or on the website.

Start tracking for free