What is temptation bundling?

Habit science · 4 min read · Updated

Temptation bundling means allowing yourself something you crave only while doing something you should do: a favorite podcast only on the treadmill, a gripping series only while folding laundry. Katherine Milkman and colleagues tested it at a gym in 2014. Visits rose at first and the effect faded, so treat it as a strong starter rather than a permanent fix.

How the original study worked

Milkman, Julia Minson and Kevin Volpp recruited gym members and split them into three groups. One group got an iPod loaded with page-turner audiobooks they could only listen to at the gym. A second group got the audiobooks on their own devices and was encouraged to listen only while exercising. A control group got neither.

At first, the gym-only group visited 51% more often than the control group, and the encouraged group 29% more. The effects declined over the following weeks, particularly after the Thanksgiving break. When the study ended, 61% of participants chose to pay for gym-only access to the audiobooks, which suggests people saw value in having the restriction imposed.

The larger follow-up

A 2020 field experiment led by Erika Kirgios, with Milkman among the authors, tested the idea at scale with 6,792 people in a four-week exercise program. Giving participants an audiobook and encouraging them to temptation bundle raised the likelihood of a weekly workout by 10 to 14%, with effects lasting up to 17 weeks after the program.

Compared with simply handing out an audiobook, the encouragement itself added only a modest benefit. The authors suggest that receiving a free audiobook as part of an exercise program already hints at the idea.

Why it works

Most good habits have the same problem: the cost is now and the benefit is later. Economists call the preference for immediate payoffs present bias. Many tempting activities have the reverse shape, enjoyable now and mildly regrettable later, such as bingeing a series at midnight.

Bundling fixes both at once. The habit gets an immediate reward, and the temptation gets a limit. You look forward to the workout because the next chapter is waiting there, and you binge less because the story only moves when you're on the bike.

How to build a bundle

A bundle needs a want and a should that can happen at the same time.

  1. List three to five things you genuinely crave: a podcast, a show, a type of coffee, a playlist, calls with a particular friend.
  2. List the habits you put off: exercise, chores, admin, a long commute on foot.
  3. Pair them where both can happen together. Audio goes with physical tasks. Visual shows go with stationary ones, like an exercise bike or ironing.
  4. Set the rule: the want happens only during the should. Not 'mostly', only.
  5. Make the rule easy to keep, for example by downloading episodes to a device you use just for walks.

Temptation bundling examples

Adapt these to whatever you actually crave, since a bundle only works if the treat pulls.

  • A true-crime podcast only while walking after dinner.
  • The next episode of a series only on the exercise bike.
  • A fancy coffee only on the walk to the gym.
  • A favorite album only while cleaning the kitchen.
  • A weekly call with your best friend only while meal prepping.
  • An audiobook only during your run.
  • A bath with a novel only after doing the week's budget check.
  • Reality TV only while folding laundry or ironing.
  • A pastry from the good bakery only after a Saturday long run, eaten on the walk home.
  • A game on your tablet only while on the rowing machine.
  • A playlist you love only while doing deep-cleaning tasks.
  • Gossip magazines only at the hair salon or while stretching.

Where it goes wrong

The most common failure is cheating on the rule. One episode watched on the sofa 'just this once' is enough to make the gym version less special. If you keep breaking the rule, choose a treat that is easier to restrict, such as audio on a device that lives in your gym bag.

The second is a treat that undoes the habit. A large dessert as the reward for a workout works against most fitness goals. A walk paired with a podcast doesn't. The third is fading novelty, which is what the original study showed. Rotate the temptation when it stops pulling: a new series, a new podcast, a new author.

Tracking the habit, not the treat

Track the behavior you're trying to build, such as 'Walk after dinner' or 'Exercise minutes', and let the treat stay unrecorded. If you start a new bundle in the middle of a month, ask ChatGPT to summarize the habit for the weeks before and after. A visible jump in the grid tells you the bundle is working. A slide back after six weeks tells you it's time to change the treat, which matches what the gym studies found.

Track it

Questions

Is temptation bundling the same as rewarding yourself?

Not quite. A reward comes after the habit. A bundle happens during it, so the habit itself becomes enjoyable. You can use both, but bundling tends to help more with starting.

What if I start cheating on the rule?

Make the treat physically harder to get outside the habit, for example by keeping it on a separate device or account. If that isn't possible, pick a different treat that is easier to restrict.

Does temptation bundling work for habits other than exercise?

The published studies focused on exercise, but the idea applies to any habit that can be paired with something enjoyable, such as chores, cooking, admin or walking. Test it on your own habit for a few weeks and compare.

Sources

Read next

All guides

Turn it into a habit you can see

Free for up to 2 habits, every feature included. Log by chatting with ChatGPT or on the website.

Start tracking for free